October 07, 2013

Comparision of Active and Passive filters


PASSIVE
ACTIVE
Advantages
  • No power supply required
  • Can handle large currents and high voltages
  • Very reliable
  • Least number of components for given filter
  • Noise arises from resistances only
  • No bandwidth limitation
  • No inductors
  • Easier to design
  • High input impedance (Zin), low output impedance (Zout) for minimal loading
  • Can produce high gains
  • Generally easier to tune
  • Small in size and weight
Disadvantages
  • Inductors large for lower frequencies
  • Some inductors (non-toroidal) may require shielding
  • Limited standard sizes, often requiring variable inductors and therefore tuning
  • Low tolerance inductors (1-2%) very expensive
  • Must be designed with consideration to input and output loading
  • Generally not amenable to miniaturization
  • No power gain possible
  • No voltage gain
  • Power supply required
  • Susceptible to inter-modulation, oscillations
  • Susceptible to parasitic from dc output offset voltage and input bias currents
  • Op amp gain bandwidth constrained
  • Op amp slew rate constrained
  • Can require many components

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comment will be published after moderation only. Do not advertise here.